EHSO home page - Free Environmental Health & Safety information, guidance and downloads of regulations and manuals online for home or EHS professional.
Environment, Health and Safety Online
The site for free, objective information you can use! 
Search the site

Table of contents of free guides, information and resources
 

Email this page to a friend, or to yourself
Bookmark and Share

Feedback
Acronyms
Services

Home   - Who are we?   -  Government Hotlines -   How to get help FAQs   -  Quick links: Today's Federal Register   - Contact Info for: EPA   - State agencies - OSHA - DOT    Regs: Search Government regs and sites    Data: Search EPA databases

 

Fall allergy  air filter Table of Contents

Search

How to get  help

Search
Government sites

Government Hotlines

Today's Federal Register

FAQs

Services

Contact Info for:
EPA  
State agencies
OSHA
DOT    

Regs:
Search Government regs and sites   

Data: Search EPA databases

States  

Related Sites

Feedback

What's new

Site home

 

Fall allergy  air filter Other Topics:

Air

Asbestos

Assessments

Auditing

Brownfields

CERCLA

DOT

Enforcement

EPA contacts

EPCRA

FedRegister

FireSafety

Groundwater

HazMats

HazWaste

Health&Safety

Hotlines

International

ISO14000

LabPacks

MSDS

NewsPlus

OSHA

PCBs

Phase I's

Pollution- Prevention

PSM

Radiation

Recycling

RiskMgmt

Soil

States

Spills

TSCA

USTs

Used Oil

Water  

Hot Dogs and Cancer Risks

horizontal rule

Is there a link between hot dogs and cancer? If so, can you reduce the risk by choosing a certain brand or type of hot dog? For years, we've heard that hot dogs, bacon and bologna are about the worst foods we could eat.  Highly processed meats loaded with fat, nitrites cow's tails and chicken beaks. Well, maybe the latter two are more urban legend, but certainly "mechanically deboned meat" is in there.

There is a Cancer Project billboard showing a pack of hot dogs coming out of a pack of cigarettes. The Cancer Project is trying to increase awareness of the dangers of processed meats, especially hot dogs. According to the PCRM and others, such as Duke University, the dangers are real and significant. Eating a hot dog every day can increase your risk of colorectal cancer by 21 percent. That’s as bad for you as smoking.

The Bottom Line:

All cured meats (hot dogs, bacon, bologna) contain nitriates and/or nitrates, and whether they are added as synthetic chemicals or as naturally occurring in celery juice and other plants, the combination of process meats and nitrites/nitrates leads to an increase in colon cancer.

Here's the explanation:

Why are nitrates and nitrites used in meat products?

1. To give cured meat such as ham, bacon, and hot dogs their pink color.
2. To prevent the growth of bacteria that can lead to food-borne illnesses such as Botulism.
3. To preserve products so they can have a longer shelf-life.
4. To provide the distinctive cured flavor that we're accustomed to in ham, bacon, and hot dogs.

The above explanation is a commonly accepted statement, this one from Applegate Farms.

What are Nitrites and Nitrates?

Sodium nitrite is a preservative used in some processed meat. Sodium nitrate is a natural antioxidant found in all kinds of vegetables (root veggies like carrots as well as leafy greens like celery and spinach) along with all sorts of fruits and grains. Basically, anything that grows from the ground uses sodium nitrate in the soil as a building block for the plant's growth. When digested or acted upon by bacteria, sodium nitrate breaks down to form sodium nitrite, which has the antimicrobial properties to fight botulism. So, it is only when sodium nitrate becomes sodium nitrite that it becomes a functional preservative. But the sodium nitrate that we consume through fruits, vegetables and grains is also converted to sodium nitrite by our digestivesystem. In other words, our bodies normally and naturally produce sodium nitrite when we eat fruits, vegetables or grains.

During the cooking process, especially under high heat, nitrites can combine with amines, naturally present in meat, to form N-nitroso compounds or Nitrosamines.form nitrosamines, which are known carcinogens. Nitrosamines create cell damage in the body and cause cancer, typically in the colon. 

What authorities say eating processed meats with nitrites in them increases the risk of canecr?

The American Institute for Cancer Research (AICR) and World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF) reviewed thousands of studies -- and continue to review ongoing research -- that reflect a hot dog-cancer connection. Its conclusion: Processed meats, including hot dogs, bacon, and deli meats, are linked to increased colorectal cancer. According to The Cancer Project:, an NIH (National Institute of Health) / AARP Diet and Health Study found that processed red meat was associated with a 10 percent increased risk of prostate cancer with every 10 grams of increased intake. A study in Taiwan showed that consumption of cured and smoked meat can increase children’s risk for leukemia. A study in Australia found that women’s risk for ovarian cancer increased as a result of eating processed meats.

Denise Snyder, MS, RD, CSO, LDN, a Duke nutrition researcher with an emphasis in cancer survivorship, says that even when eaten in moderation, hot dogs are a risky food. She points to research showing that eating 3.5 ounces of processed meat every day (24.5 ounces per week) increases the risk of colorectal cancer by 36 percent when compared to someone who eats no processed meat.

What can you do? Read the Label

If you have to have a hot dog, Snyder recommends white hot dogs, also called bockworst, which do not have nitrates added.

Turkey dogs, chicken dogs, kosher, and other ethnic varieties all carry the same threat as beef hot dogs because they are still processed meats that may have unhealthy preservatives added.

What about the popular Vienna Meats brand?

The nutrition page on the Vienna Beef website  shows us the following:

Skinless Hot Dog Ingredients:  Beef, Water, Salt, Corn Syrup, Dextrose, Mustard, Natural Flavorings and Coloring, Garlic Juice (Garlic Juice, Salt), Sodium Erythorbate, Sodium Nitrite, Extractives of Paprika.
Nutrition Facts:
Serving Size: 1 Frank 8:1(56g)
Servings Per Container: About 80

Sodium Erythorbate is a form of Vitamin C, required by the USDA to reduce the amount of nitrites added, but the nitrites are clearly still present.

So, no matter how the Vienna Beef company attempts to “spin” it; their hot dogs do contain added chemical nitrites, and therefore should be avoided. Interestingly, their nutritional information on their website does not include fat, saturated fat or other key aspects of nutritional information that their customers would want to know.  Why?  Is it because those facts are not positive?

And Kosher Hebrew National?

Their web page lists the ingredients as “Beef, Water, Contains 2% or less of: Salt, Sodium Lactate, Spice, Hydrolyzed Soy Protein, Paprika, Sodium Diacetate, Garlic Powder, Sodium Erythorbate, Sodium Nitrite, Flavorings. CONTAINS: Soy”

Again, added sodium nitrite.

Oscar Meyer?

Oscar Meyer has their own line of of nitrite-free hot dogs, and you could argue that these are better than those with added nitrites, but again, they make up for it by adding celery juice, which naturally contains nitrates.

What about Organic Hot Dogs?

If you think that buying uncured organic hot dogs alleviates the problem, then you may be disappointed. It’s the nitrites and nitrates in processed meats such as hot dogs that are linked with all sorts of cancers. And while uncured franks have “no added nitrates,” Consumer Reports testing found that Applegate Farms, Coleman Natural, and Whole Ranch contained nitrates and nitrites at levels comparable to many of the cured models, due to naturally occurring nitrates and nitrites in seasonings, like celery juice. Are these better or worse than “added nitrites”? 

While both have nitrate, according to The New York Times: A study published earlier this year in The Journal of Food Protection found that natural hot dogs had anywhere from one-half to 10 times the amount of nitrite that conventional hot dogs contained. Natural bacon had from about a third as much nitrite as a conventional brand to more than twice as much.

Are there any “safe” hot dogs?

Not really, but you can reduce the risk somewhat by at least choosing those without added nitrites and without added natural sources of nitrite, like celery juice, or lowever levels of either. When shopping for hot dogs, look for fresh meats with no preservatives added. Be sure to read labels carefully and avoid those listing nitrates or nitrites in the ingredients. But, finding hot dogs without either synthetic or natural nitrites is almost impossible.

Also, consider healthier alternatives to traditional hot dogs, such as vegetarian hot dogs, or cook fruits and vegetables on the grill instead.

horizontal rule

Conclusions

Common sense says we should avoid eating processed meats, such as hot dogs, bacon, bologna, sausages, etc.; even if they manufacturers claim they are healthy, organic, or even nitrite free. TheNew York Times: article concludes:

But many scientists say the evidence of health risks remains persuasive. While the occasional hot dog or piece of bacon is probably O.K., they point out that high levels of salt and saturated fat in processed meats also contribute to health problems.

“What’s very clear is that consuming processed meats is related to higher risk of diabetes, heart attacks and colon cancer,” said Dr. Walter C. Willet, chairman of the nutrition department of the Harvard School of Public Health. “If you tweak the cured meat a little bit like some of these new products, that’s no guarantee that’s going to make it any better.”

So, try to only eat hot dogs, bacon and bologna a few times a year, especially if you are a child or pregnant woman.  And when you do eat them, look for those which are lower in fat and salt. You can olso eat frozen meats, frozen sausages which are not cured, and have no added nitrite, synthetic or natural.
horizontal rule

References and external links

Many of the references are embedded in the links included in the article above.  Here are some others:

bullet Duke University Health
bullet Nitrites and Nitrates (University of Ohio)

Back to top

 

 

Contact information

Environmental Health & Safety Online
EHSO ( Benivia, LLC ), 12850 Hwy 9, Suite 600-196, Atlanta, GA 30004 - Privacy Policy
 

Table of Contents to free guidance and resources: http://www.ehso.com/contents.php

Environmental and safety services for business - training, consulting, assessments, ISO14000, report and permit preparations and expert testimony: http://www.ehso.com/EHSservices/enviserv.htm

If you provide environmental, safety, transportation, or related services or products; such as training, consulting, management, etc., EHSO would like to hear from you.  We are looking for quality professionals to offer their services as affiliates. Please contact us via feedback .

Email:

How to get help with your questions
Copyright 2014 EHSO - Online since 1998